Sign In
❮ Back to Search

54 PLATOFF STREET, Niagara-on-the-Lake (Town), Ontario, L0S1J0

MLS: X12485076 | House (Freehold)

$1,550,000

❮ Back to Properties

Property Description

Welcome to Abigail House - a quintessential Niagara-on-the-Lake retreat with rare flexibility, charm, and income-generating potential. Located on a quiet tree-lined street just steps from Old Town's shops, restaurants, and theatre district, this property blends storybook character with modern comfort across two distinct dwellings. At the front of the property, Abigail House operates as a licensed and long-established short-term rental, known for its warmth, heritage details, and beautifully maintained gardens. Behind it, the striking Carriage House - finished in red Mabec siding with rustic beams and an artist-loft feel - provides exceptional versatility. The sellers use this private space when in town, and its self-contained layout (kitchen, 2 bedrooms, and 1 bath) offers multiple uses, including extended family living, guest accommodations, or additional rental capacity. Inside, both dwellings offer inviting spaces filled with natural light, wood floors, vaulted ceilings, and serene garden views. Courtyards and mature landscaping create a peaceful setting ideal for quiet mornings or evenings under the stars. Regarding financing: This property is licensed for short-term rental use. Buyers are encouraged to speak with their mortgage professional for information on available financing options related to properties with short term licensing as there are mortgages available per individual profile. HST applicability is tied to current short-term rental use. For buyers intending personal or long-term residential use, HST may be deferred or not applicable - buyers are encouraged to confirm with their accountant. A truly rare opportunity to live, host, and invest in one of Niagara-on-the-Lake's most sought-after neighbourhoods. (Please note: Realtor.ca displays the combined room count for both dwellings.) (id:64974)

Directions: Cross Streets: Platoff St and Davy St. ** Directions: North on King St. East on.

Quick Facts

  • Property Type: House (Freehold)
  • Bedrooms: 6 (6 above)
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Ownership: Freehold
  • Attached: No
  • Parking: 5 spaces (Detached Garage, Garage)
  • Frontage: 60 ft (18.3 m)

Costs

  • Annual Taxes: $6,153.67

Listing Provided by: SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY, BROKERAGE
Board: Niagara Association of REALTORS®
Data provided via CREA DDF®.

Detailed Features

📋 Revisions Available 1 change▼ Click to expand

Interior & Systems

  • Heating: Forced air, Natural gas
  • Cooling: Central air conditioning
  • Basement: Unfinished, N/A
  • Appliances: Washer, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Stove, Dryer, Microwave, Water Heater - Tankless
  • Security: Controlled entry

Exterior & Construction

  • Exterior: Brick
  • Foundation: Stone, Concrete
  • Sewer: Sanitary sewer
  • Water: Municipal water

Lot & Land

  • Frontage: 60 ft (18.3 m)
  • Features: Carpet Free

Community & Neighbourhood

  • Neighbourhood: 101 - Town

Room Details (19 rooms)

Main level
Sitting room13'9" x 9'9" (133 ft²)
Living room13'0" x 10'6" (136 ft²)
Dining room12'6" x 10'6" (131 ft²)
Kitchen9'9" x 9'0" (87 ft²)
Pantry6'9" x 5'1" (35 ft²)
Bedroom13'9" x 11'7" (160 ft²)
Bathroom11'9" x 5'0" (59 ft²)
Second level
Bathroom9'7" x 6'9" (65 ft²)
Family room16'6" x 13'0" (214 ft²)
Bedroom12'7" x 10'6" (132 ft²)
Bedroom 210'5" x 9'5" (98 ft²)
Bathroom10'0" x 8'1" (81 ft²)
Bedroom13'9" x 10'6" (144 ft²)
Bedroom 213'1" x 10'6" (137 ft²)
Bedroom 313'1" x 9'7" (126 ft²)
Basement
Laundry room10'0" x 6'9" (68 ft²)
Utility room29'11" x 19'2" (574 ft²)
Utility room20'0" x 10'0" (200 ft²)
Ground level
Kitchen17'6" x 9'10" (172 ft²)

Listing Information

MLS® NumberX12485076
BoardNiagara
Originating SystemNiagara Association of REALTORS®
BrokerageSOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY, BROKERAGE
Date ListedOctober 28, 2025
Last UpdatedFebruary 25, 2026

Listing History

Buy/Sell/Terminated/Expired listing history for 54 PLATOFF STREET, Niagara-on-the-Lake (Town), Ontario, L0S1J0

DateDays on MarketPriceEventListing ID
🔄2/25/2026119Status ChangedX12485076
10/28/20250$1,550,000For SaleX12485076
10/28/20250$1,550,000ListedX12485076

Location & Neighborhood

📍54 PLATOFF STREET, Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, L0S1J0
🗺️ Open in Google Maps🚶‍♂️ Launch Street View

🚗 Travel times

Neighborhood Walkability

Mortgage & Cost Calculators

Nearby Homes (Within 2km)

Similar Homes

Similar Properties

Active Comparables
Rent Comparables
Sold Comparables
Rented Comparables

No rental comparables found in this area.

Sold Comparables

Access to sold property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon

Rented Comparables

Access to rented property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon