204 COTTINGHAM STREET, Toronto (Casa Loma), Ontario, M4V1C5
MLS: C12991686 | House (Freehold)
$2,895,000
Property Description
Tucked into the Republic of Rathnelly, one of Toronto's most unique and tightly held neighbourhoods, this striking Gable-Front Victorian offers a rare combination of scale, character, and location. Set on a quiet, tree-lined street where neighbours know each other and homes rarely come to market, this is the kind of address buyers wait years for. Inside, soaring ceilings on every level create a sense of volume rarely found, with a main floor that blends elegance and function through a formal living room with wood burning fireplace, a dining room with gas fireplace, and a kitchen that anchors daily life and entertaining. The second floor offers two bedrooms plus a flexible den easily converted back to a fifth, along with laundry and a primary suite with California Closets built-ins. The third floor adds two more bedrooms, including one with an integrated study area, and a walkout terrace above the city. A largely unspoiled lower level with wine cellar and side walkout offers exceptional future potential. Detached garage via shared drive with potential for additional rear parking. Steps to Summerhill, Nordheimer Ravine, Pump Park, transit, and within the coveted Brown School catchment. A rare opportunity in a true neighbourhood setting. (id:64974)
Quick Facts
- Property Type: House (Freehold)
- Bedrooms: 6 (4 above, 2 below)
- Bathrooms: 4 (1 half)
- Ownership: Freehold
- Attached: Yes
- Fireplaces: Yes
- Parking: 1.0 space (Detached Garage, Garage)
- Frontage: 26 ft (7.9 m)
Costs
- Annual Taxes: $15,492.01 (2026)
Listing Provided by: ROYAL LEPAGE/J & D DIVISION
Board: Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Data provided via CREA DDF®.
Detailed Features
Interior & Systems
- Heating: Forced air, Natural gas
- Cooling: Central air conditioning
- Basement: Unfinished, Separate entrance, N/A, N/A
- Appliances: Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Range, Microwave, Hood Fan, Window Coverings, Garage door opener
Exterior & Construction
- Exterior: Brick
- Foundation: Stone, Brick
- Fencing: Fenced yard
- Sewer: Sanitary sewer
- Water: Municipal water
Lot & Land
- Frontage: 26 ft (7.9 m)
Community & Neighbourhood
- Building: Fireplace(s)
- Neighbourhood: Casa Loma
Listing Information
Listing History
MLS listing activity for 204 COTTINGHAM STREET, Toronto (Casa Loma), Ontario, M4V1C5 — dates reflect when changes were recorded in the DDF
🚗 Travel times
Neighborhood Walkability
Mortgage & Cost Calculators
Nearby Homes ?Nearby Homes — Search CriteriaSearch Radius1 kmPrice Range±5%Match BedroomsYesMatch BathroomsYes
74B RATHNELLY AVENUE, Toronto (Casa Loma)
House$21,000/mo
Listing Courtesy of RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
74B RATHNELLY AVENUE, Toronto (Casa Loma)
House$3,849,000
Listing Courtesy of RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
203 - 40 OAKLANDS AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$825,000
$2,890/yr taxListing Courtesy of CHESTNUT PARK REAL ESTATE LIMITED
56 POPLAR PLAINS ROAD, Toronto (Casa Loma)
House$3,195,000
$14,923/yr taxListing Courtesy of CHESTNUT PARK REAL ESTATE LIMITED
303 - 285 AVENUE ROAD, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$1,670,000
$7,688/yr taxListing Courtesy of ROYAL LEPAGE SIGNATURE REALTY
131 ALCORN AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
House$2,268,000
Listing Courtesy of CHESTNUT PARK REAL ESTATE LIMITED
2 - 11A CLARENDON AVENUE, Toronto (Casa Loma)
Condo - Row / Townhouse$1,475,000
$7,646/yr taxListing Courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.
13 - 423 AVENUE ROAD, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$1,275,000
$5,965/yr taxListing Courtesy of SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA
1 - 423 AVENUE ROAD, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$2,400/mo
Listing Courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.
201 - 113 DUPONT STREET, Toronto (Annex)
Condo - Apartment$2,895,000
$10,716/yr taxListing Courtesy of HARVEY KALLES REAL ESTATE LTD.
PH01 - 113 DUPONT STREET, Toronto (Annex)
Condo - Apartment$2,995,000
$12,835/yr taxListing Courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.
406 - 150 FARNHAM AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$534,900
$2,541/yr taxListing Courtesy of REAL ESTATE HOMEWARD
432 - 150 FARNHAM AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$2,100/mo
Listing Courtesy of ROYAL LEPAGE/J & D DIVISION
92 WOODLAWN AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
House$5,995,000
$24,357/yr taxListing Courtesy of SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA
130 B FARNHAM AVENUE, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
House$6,999,900
$21,258/yr taxListing Courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS REFERRED URBAN REALTY
Similar Homes ?Similar Homes — Search CriteriaSearch Radius5 kmPrice Range±5%Match Home TypeYesMatch BedroomsYes
68 LYNNHAVEN ROAD, Toronto (Englemount-Lawrence)
House$2,899,000
$5,157/yr taxListing Courtesy of RE/MAX IMPERIAL REALTY INC.
313 BROADWAY AVENUE, Toronto (Bridle Path-Sunnybrook-York Mills)
House$2,995,000
$12,846/yr taxListing Courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.
107A SCOLLARD STREET, Toronto (Annex)
House$2,895,000
$10,806/yr taxListing Courtesy of LANDLORD REALTY INC.
201 - 113 DUPONT STREET, Toronto (Annex)
Condo - Apartment$2,895,000
$10,716/yr taxListing Courtesy of HARVEY KALLES REAL ESTATE LTD.
6 WELLER CRESCENT, Vaughan (Maple)
House$2,899,000
$11,723/yr taxListing Courtesy of SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY CANADA
2 TIDNISH COURT, King (Nobleton)
House$2,899,000
$11,889/yr taxListing Courtesy of RE/MAX HALLMARK YORK GROUP REALTY LTD.
394 CONNAUGHT AVENUE, Toronto (Newtonbrook West)
House$2,899,000
$12,910/yr taxListing Courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.
99 COON'S ROAD, Richmond Hill (Oak Ridges)
House$2,899,000
$14,497/yr taxListing Courtesy of HC REALTY GROUP INC.
523 BRIAR HILL AVENUE, Toronto (Forest Hill North)
House$2,899,000
$15,783/yr taxListing Courtesy of RE/MAX REALTRON REALTY INC.
44A ALCINA AVENUE, Toronto (Wychwood)
House$2,899,000
Listing Courtesy of SIXROOFS REALTY
11150 MENZIES COURT, Milton (Brookville/Haltonville)
House$2,899,000
$11,663/yr taxListing Courtesy of RIGHT AT HOME REALTY
SUITE 1002 - 63 ST CLAIR AVENUE W, Toronto (Yonge-St. Clair)
Condo - Apartment$2,899,000
$13,733/yr taxListing Courtesy of CHESTNUT PARK REAL ESTATE LIMITED
176 FIRST NATIONS TRAIL, Vaughan (Kleinburg)
House$2,899,000
$11,782/yr taxListing Courtesy of UPSTATE REALTY INC.
13905 KENNEDY ROAD, Caledon
House$2,899,000
$9,950/yr taxListing Courtesy of Sotheby's International Realty Canada, Brokerage
38 WILLOW DRIVE, Tiny
House$2,899,000
$6,428/yr taxListing Courtesy of RE/MAX By The Bay Brokerage
Similar Properties ?Active Comparables — Search CriteriaSearch Radius2 kmPrice Range±5%Match Home TypeYesMatch BedroomsYes
No active comparables found in this area.
Sold Comparables
Access to sold property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.
Coming SoonRented Comparables
Access to rented property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.
Coming SoonBook a Viewing
204 COTTINGHAM STREET, Toronto (Casa Loma), Ontario, M4V1C5