Sign In
❮ Back to Search

191-221 PENNIE AVENUE, Tehkummah, Ontario, P0P2C0

MLS: X12114827 | House (Freehold)

$4,950,000

❮ Back to Properties

Property Description

Welcome to "The Estate on Michael's Bay", one of the most exclusive properties on Manitoulin Island - an exceptional 116-acre waterfront estate featuring 928 ft of pristine shoreline on the crystal-clear waters of Lake Huron. The estate consists of a 9,000 sq ft log home, a 3,000 sq ft guest house, a 3,600 sq ft heated workshop, a private 2,500 ft airstrip and a private lake. Minutes from South Baymouth and just 85 minutes by plane from Toronto, this gated property offers ultimate privacy, convenience, and luxury. At the heart of the estate lies a breathtaking main residence that blends timeless log construction with concrete floors and radiant in-floor heating. A dramatic, floor-to-ceiling 4-sided wood-burning stone fireplace anchors the vaulted great room, surrounded by living, music, study, and sitting areas. The breakfast nook offers a place to relax in front of a wood-burning fireplace. The kitchen features a waterfall island, hidden pantry, wine cooler, Thor appliances, and beamed ceilings. A mud/laundry room, a guest suite with ensuite, and a 2-piece bath complete the main floor. Upstairs, a floating staircase with glass railing leads to the primary suite's sitting area, 6-piece ensuite with soaking tub, double showers, dual vanities, and private deck. The lower level offers a games room with wet bar, fitness studio, family room, walkout bedroom, full bath, and unfinished spaces to add your touch. Outside, enjoy a hot tub, limestone waterfall, screen sunroom, landscaped terraces, and al fresco dining. The guest house includes 4 beds, 2.5 baths and a garage. The workshop features 3 oversized garage doors, EV charger, and an unfinished apartment. Backing onto 500+ acres of protected conservation land with hiking trails, this rare offering combines elegance, adventure, and legacy. Whether you're seeking a refined second home, a family compound, or a nature-infused escape from city life, this extraordinary property delivers a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. (id:64974)

Directions: Cross Streets: Hwys 6/542. ** Directions: From South Baymouth take Hwy 6 north to Side Rd 10 to 6 Concession Rd to right turn onto Side Road 15 to left onto Government Rd to Michaels Bay Rd and continue onto Pennie Ave. to 191.

Quick Facts

  • Property Type: House (Freehold)
  • Style: Log house/cabin
  • Bedrooms: 7 (4 above, 3 below)
  • Bathrooms: 7 (2 half)
  • Ownership: Freehold
  • Attached: No
  • Fireplaces: 2
  • Parking: 11 spaces (Detached Garage, Garage)
  • Frontage: 929 ft (283.1 m)

Costs

  • Annual Taxes: $29,957.00 (2024)

Listing Provided by: Sotheby's International Realty Canada
Board: OnePoint Association of REALTORS®
Data provided via CREA DDF®.

Detailed Features

Interior & Systems

  • Heating: Radiant heat, Propane
  • Cooling: Ventilation system, None
  • Basement: Walk out, N/A
  • Appliances: All, Water purifier, Hot Tub, Barbeque, Oven - Built-In, Water Heater
  • Flooring: Concrete, Laminate, Ceramic, Cushion/Lino/Vinyl
  • Utilities: Electricity
  • Security: Security system

Exterior & Construction

  • Style: Log house/cabin
  • Exterior: Log
  • Foundation: Concrete
  • Sewer: Septic System
  • Water: Drilled Well

Lot & Land

  • Frontage: 929 ft (283.1 m)
  • Features: Wooded area, Sloping, Partially cleared, Backs on greenbelt, Flat site, Conservation/green belt, Dry, Guest Suite
  • View: Lake view, View, View of water, Direct Water View
  • Waterfront: Island
  • Water Body: Lake Huron
  • Zoning: RU

Community & Neighbourhood

  • Building: Fireplace(s)

Room Details (34 rooms)

Main level
Living room15'9" x 19'4" (304 ft²)
Laundry room12'4" x 12'0" (148 ft²)
Sunroom33'6" x 13'6" (452 ft²)
Sitting room16'11" x 32'8" (553 ft²)
Living room17'0" x 15'0" (255 ft²)
Media22'7" x 29'10" (673 ft²)
Dining room15'6" x 11'6" (178 ft²)
Kitchen17'0" x 15'0" (255 ft²)
Bathroom5'5" x 5'2" (28 ft²)
Laundry room9'6" x 5'2" (49 ft²)
Eating area23'8" x 30'1" (712 ft²)
Dining room23'6" x 19'6" (458 ft²)
Kitchen11'7" x 23'3" (269 ft²)
Pantry12'3" x 9'10" (120 ft²)
Bedroom23'5" x 19'5" (455 ft²)
Bathroom11'5" x 8'4" (95 ft²)
Bathroom7'8" x 9'9" (75 ft²)
Second level
Primary Bedroom49'3" x 14'11" (735 ft²)
Bathroom33'5" x 27'11" (933 ft²)
Lower level
Family room28'10" x 25'6" (735 ft²)
Bedroom 221'6" x 18'10" (405 ft²)
Exercise room19'3" x 15'8" (302 ft²)
Games room21'5" x 13'11" (298 ft²)
Bathroom9'10" x 5'10" (57 ft²)
Utility room10'5" x 13'0" (136 ft²)
Utility room21'7" x 6'2" (133 ft²)
Family room13'5" x 11'6" (155 ft²)
Bedroom 316'5" x 13'7" (223 ft²)
Bedroom 413'7" x 12'4" (168 ft²)
Bathroom7'10" x 5'7" (44 ft²)
Utility room9'6" x 8'7" (82 ft²)
Upper Level
Primary Bedroom14'10" x 15'0" (222 ft²)
Bedroom 214'9" x 15'1" (223 ft²)
Bathroom8'4" x 6'8" (56 ft²)

Listing Information

MLS® NumberX12114827
BoardOnePoint
Originating SystemOnePoint Association of REALTORS®
BrokerageSotheby's International Realty Canada
Date ListedMay 1, 2025
Last UpdatedFebruary 25, 2026

Listing History

Buy/Sell/Terminated/Expired listing history for 191-221 PENNIE AVENUE, Tehkummah, Ontario, P0P2C0

DateDays on MarketPriceEventListing ID
🔄2/25/2026299Status ChangedX12114827
5/1/20250$4,950,000For SaleX12114827
5/1/20250$4,950,000ListedX12114827

Location & Neighborhood

📍191-221 PENNIE AVENUE, Tehkummah, Ontario, P0P2C0
🗺️ Open in Google Maps🚶‍♂️ Launch Street View

🚗 Travel times

Neighborhood Walkability

Mortgage & Cost Calculators

Nearby Homes (Within 2km)

Similar Homes

Similar Properties

Active Comparables
Rent Comparables
Sold Comparables
Rented Comparables

No rental comparables found in this area.

Sold Comparables

Access to sold property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon

Rented Comparables

Access to rented property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon