Sign In
❮ Back to Search

10 & 11 METHODIST ISLAND, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

MLS: S12208769 | House (Freehold)

$625,000

❮ Back to Properties

Property Description

This charming family cottage offers the perfect blend of comfort, privacy, and classic cottage living just a 5-minute boat ride from Victoria Harbour with easy access to Foodland, the LCBO, and other amenities. Located on sought-after Methodist Island, this 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom retreat features a bright, open-concept layout with vaulted ceilings and a cozy loft overlooking the kitchen, dining area, and living room. A wood stove anchors the living space, creating the ideal atmosphere for relaxed evenings. Step outside onto the spacious front deck, perfect for dining al fresco or enjoying quiet mornings overlooking the yard. A fire pit invites late-night s'mores and stories under the stars, while a separate bunkie with its own screened porch and double bunk beds offers extra space for kids or guests. Boat-access only and surrounded by nature, this peaceful cottage is the quintessential Georgian Bay escape. Whether you're swimming off the dock, relaxing in the sun, or heading into town for supplies, this property delivers the best of both seclusion and convenience. (id:64974)

Directions: Cross Streets: Hwy 12 and William St. ** Directions: By Boat from Victoria Harbour to the east side of Methodist Island. SOP.

Quick Facts

  • Property Type: House (Freehold)
  • Style: Raised bungalow
  • Bedrooms: 3 (3 above)
  • Bathrooms: 1
  • Ownership: Freehold
  • Attached: No
  • Fireplaces: 1
  • Frontage: 201 ft (61.2 m)

Costs

  • Annual Taxes: $3,314.00 (2025)

Listing Provided by: Sotheby's International Realty Canada
Board: OnePoint Association of REALTORS®
Data provided via CREA DDF®.

Detailed Features

Interior & Systems

  • Heating: Other
  • Cooling: None
  • Basement: None
  • Appliances: Refrigerator, Stove
  • Flooring: Laminate
  • Utilities: Electricity, Electricity Connected
  • Fireplace Features: Woodstove

Exterior & Construction

  • Style: Raised bungalow
  • Exterior: Wood
  • Foundation: Wood/Piers
  • Sewer: Septic System
  • Water: Lake/River Water Intake

Lot & Land

  • Frontage: 201 ft (61.2 m)
  • Features: Wooded area, Partially cleared, Level
  • View: View, View of water, Direct Water View
  • Waterfront: Island
  • Water Body: Georgian Bay
  • Zoning: RS-4

Community & Neighbourhood

  • Neighbourhood: Port McNicoll

Room Details (8 rooms)

Main level
Living room19'1" x 12'6" (239 ft²)
Dining room12'6" x 10'11" (137 ft²)
Kitchen14'6" x 8'10" (128 ft²)
Bedroom11'4" x 11'1" (126 ft²)
Bedroom 29'0" x 7'11" (71 ft²)
Bedroom 311'4" x 11'0" (124 ft²)
Bathroom8'4" x 7'2" (60 ft²)
Upper Level
Loft11'11" x 11'11" (142 ft²)

Listing Information

MLS® NumberS12208769
BoardOnePoint
Originating SystemOnePoint Association of REALTORS®
BrokerageSotheby's International Realty Canada
Date ListedJune 10, 2025
Last UpdatedFebruary 25, 2026

Listing History

Buy/Sell/Terminated/Expired listing history for 10 & 11 METHODIST ISLAND, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

DateDays on MarketPriceEventListing ID
🔄2/25/2026259Status ChangedS12208769
6/10/20250$625,000For SaleS12208769
6/10/20250$625,000ListedS12208769

Location & Neighborhood

📍10 & 11 METHODIST ISLAND, Tay, Ontario, L0K1R0
🗺️ Open in Google Maps🚶‍♂️ Launch Street View

🚗 Travel times

Neighborhood Walkability

Mortgage & Cost Calculators

Nearby Homes (Within 2km)

Similar Homes

Similar Properties

Active Comparables
Rent Comparables
Sold Comparables
Rented Comparables

No rental comparables found in this area.

Sold Comparables

Access to sold property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon

Rented Comparables

Access to rented property data requires a registered and verified account with TRREB DDF integration.

Coming Soon